People from San Diego never need to be asked twice to brag about where they live. Most never need to be asked but those who brag will almost always talk about how our Mexican food is better than anywhere else in the country. A select few will even argue that certain parts of San Diego have better Mexican food than other parts of San Diego. An even select-er few will argue that we have better Mexican food than Mexico does but those people might be missing the point. The truth can be boiled down to this: short of going to Mexico (a staggering 20 minute trip from my front door), San Diego has the best Mexican food. Now, I’m not talking about high end Mexico-fusion dining or trendy molecular gastronomy versions of a burrito-type places. I’m talking the classic, hole-in-the-wall, cash-only, bars-on-the-windows, they-need-to-go-get-the-one-lady-who-speaks-kinda-okay-English-to-take-your-order, neon-painted-lettering-that-covers-the-windows and has-Horchata-on-tap type place AKA THE BEST FOOD EVER. When it’s 2am and you are knee-walking drunk, this is the place your friends take you to for food that will hug your soul. It’s the place you take out-of-towners to for a life-changing experience that we who live here all had: The day you discovered what real SoCal Mexican food is. THAT’S the shit worth bragging about.
Naturally, when I set out on this quest, I was inundated with suggestions for local Mexican joints from local friends. I had to choose carefully, but honestly it’s hard to go wrong with these kinds of places. This week’s challenge was El Pollo Grill in Lemon Grove, which is NOT to be confused with fast food chain El Pollo Loco. I love Mexican food and I love chicken so this was a labor of love for yours truly and my loyal dining companions:
Aimee-Roommate since the 90’s, BFF, allergic to hot dogs and therefore labeled a commie by many
Chris-Attorney, lifelong food snob, loves good Scotch and gay jeans
Mike & Marjy-The package deal, a pair of my favorite foodies who once served me cake on a stick in the snowy mountains (true story)
El Pollo Grill is a down-home “elbows on the table” type joint but is certainly not high on the sketch-o-meter of Mexican places I’ve been to, locally. Good food is good food so I don’t judge. I’m not a big fan of chicken on the bone. I will eat it but prefer not to. Fortunately, El Pollo Grill offers a myriad of others way to get your chicken on. I took advantage of a few of them and left the chicken mauling to my cohorts. Aimee ordered the half chicken dinner, which came with tortillas, rice & beans. She also had a fish taco on the side. She said the chicken was juicy and well seasoned with a great crispy skin. Something she (and everyone else who ordered it) found odd was the choice of beans. Rather than the usual refried or black beans, El Pollo Grill serves pinto beans. While they were not badly prepared, Aimee mentioned she would have preferred refried beans with her dinner. Her grilled fish taco was really good with a fantastic sauce.
Chris ordered the “Special C” (also his break dancing name back in ’84): 4-piece combo with rice, beans and tortillas. Chris enjoyed his meal but found it a little plain. When he eats white meat chicken, which is rare, he finds it a bit dry. Such was the case here, even though he admitted the chicken itself had excellent flavor. He is also not a fan of pinto beans.
Mike and Marjy shared the 12 piece grilled chicken with rice, beans and corn tortillas. They also ordered a side of jalapeno carrots. They agreed with Chris on both counts that their chicken was flavorful but a bit on the dry side (which is admittedly better than being undercooked). Marjy smartly pointed out that the true test of any Mexican place is the quality of their beans and/or rice and both were great with moist tortillas, which is important. Mike also added that the Horchata (A sweet, rice-based drink) was on point.
I ordered 3 a’ la carte dishes: 5 rolled tacos, a chicken quesadilla and Pollo Asado Fries. The rolled tacos, served with house made guacamole, were crispy, fresh and flavorful. The chicken was a bit dry but the flavors were damned near perfect compared to some other rolled tacos I’ve had. The pollo asado fries were shoes string-cut french fries covered in marinated chicken, guacamole, sour cream and a massive layer of shredded cheese. Something like this would’ve been akin to food of the Gods back in my heavier drinking days. The me of today enjoyed the burst of flavors on this shareable plate of goodness. The food here is kind of large…
Which brings me to the quesadilla. It was huge. Like, the size of a newborn. I had no idea there was going to be so much food or I would have most certainly scaled back my order. Full of chicken and rich cheese, this quesadilla had more of a Mexican Calzone feel to it but it was really good.
Overall feelings on El Pollo Grill were positive. We all agreed that the place was a great value. Tons of big food at a great price. I got 3 meals for barely more than $20. While nothing was Earth shattering we all agreed that it would be a fantastic choice for a place to take out-of-towners for their first taste of “real Mexican food”. I say thumbs up, hit it up if you’re in the area for a good lunch or dinner.
Further reading: http://www.elpollogrill.com/


















